Allstate Insurance Company

Arbitration Claims Representative

In short

A remote Claims Arbitration Specialist role at National General (part of Allstate) resolving intercompany auto claim disputes through arbitration and negotiation. The role involves investigating advanced auto claims, analyzing coverage, liability and damages, preparing arbitration submissions, and determining subrogation or fraud potential. It demands strong analytical, negotiation, and written communication skills plus insurance claims expertise, and does not include supervisory duties. Based in the US, no visa sponsorship is offered.

Company Overview
National General is a part of The Allstate Corporation, which means we have the same innovative drive that keeps us a step ahead of our customers' evolving needs. We offer home, auto and accident and health insurance, as well as other specialty niche insurance products, through a large network of independent insurance agents, as well as directly to consumers.
Job Description
At National General, we are committed to delivering fair and timely claim resolutions while providing exceptional service to our customers and business partners. As a Claims Arbitration Specialist, you will play a critical role in resolving intercompany claim disputes through arbitration and negotiation. You will review claim files, analyze liability and damages, prepare persuasive arbitration submissions, and represent the company's position in arbitration forums to achieve favorable outcomes.
This role requires strong analytical thinking, attention to detail, and the ability to effectively communicate and negotiate complex claim matters. Successful candidates will leverage their claims expertise to evaluate evidence, support sound business decisions, and contribute to recovery and expense management objectives.
Use your knowledge of subrogation and arbitration claims investigation to help drive fair and strategic recoveries. This role offers the opportunity to deepen your expertise, collaborate with experienced professionals, and see the direct impact of your work every day.
Key Responsibilities
•Applies advanced understanding of insurance policies written by the company, the industry, and organizational relationships within the company and department
•Handles investigation regarding all aspects of advanced auto claims (coverage, liability and damages) with the exercise of discretion and independence within increased level of authority
•For claims involving injuries (if handled), learns how to review, evaluate, and negotiate basic to moderate injury claims
•Recognizes and identifies body parts of a vehicle and understanding other potential property damage
•Identifies customer needs and works to meet those needs using appropriate customer service skills
•Determines subrogation or fraud potential and how to handle
•Applies increased experience in the Adjuster II level or a rotation into a specialty position (Coverage, Investigation Specialist, Total Loss, Initial Handler, Extended Handler, etc.)
Supervisory Responsibilities
•This job does not have supervisory duties.
As a requirement of employment, individuals who currently hold an active insurance license must terminate all existing appointments prior to onboarding and must not hold any outside appointments at any point during employment. Applicants seeking an adjuster role who also hold a resident producer license must formally surrender that license when instructed to by the licensing team. By proceeding with the application process, applicants acknowledge and accept these licensing requirements and agree to comply.
Skills
Arbitration, Insurance Claims, Written Communication
Compensation
Base compensation offered for this role is:
•Consultant I: $53,500.00 - $77,800.00
•Consultant II: $56,000.00 - $82,500.00
Salary is based on experience and qualifications. Total compensation for this role is comprised of several factors, including the base compensation outlined above, plus incentive pay (i.e. commission, bonus, etc.) if applicable for the role.
Company Background
National General Holdings Corp., a member of the Allstate family of companies, is headquartered in New York City. National General traces its roots to 1939, has a financial strength rating of A– (excellent) from A.M. Best, and provides personal and commercial automobile, homeowners, umbrella, recreational vehicle, motorcycle, supplemental health, and other niche insurance products. We are a specialty personal lines insurance holding company. Through our subsidiaries, we provide a variety of insurance products, including personal and commercial automobile, homeowners, umbrella, recreational vehicle, supplemental health, lender-placed and other niche insurance products.
Visa Sponsorship
Candidates must possess authorization to work in the United States, as it is not our practice to sponsor individuals for work visas.
Work From Home Setup
Allstate provides a comprehensive technology setup, including a laptop, monitors, headset, keyboard, and mouse. Employees eligible to work from home also receive a monthly connectivity reimbursement to help offset internet costs.
When working from home, you must have a dedicated, private workspace free from distractions, along with appropriate desk and seating. Reliable internet is required, with minimum speeds of 50 MB download and 5 MB upload.

Stop applying.
Get referred.

$10 in free credits

In just 60 seconds, fully on autopilot — Eraldt's AI agents read your CV, map the roles you fit, find live vacancies and the people who can refer you, write personal emails, and get you referred.

This isn't an application: your CV doesn't go to the company, and we don't promise a referral for this exact role.

Discover who else lands interviews on autopilot